Miami Dolphins ~ Jacksonville Jaguars : Trade Deal(Approved)

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

Phins get :

Byron Leftwich [82]
Reggie Nelson [82]
Marcus Stroud [94]
Ernest Wilford [77]
Dennis Northcutt [74]

Jags get :

Trent Green [85]
Renaldo Hill [80]
Keith Traylor [84]
Marty Booker [82]
Kelly Campbell [66]
MIA's 1st Round Pick
MIA's 2nd Round Pick

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

I accept this offering.

max1 · Posts: 193 Join date: 2007-09-04 Age: 16 Location: Ohio

phins need to give more on this one.

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

max1 wrote:

phins need to give more on this one.

I agree IMO Phins need to add another 80 player

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

It's even'd out. I got 2 positions I needed help in, and he did too. and I gave him a 2nd rounder.

_________________
Miami Dolphins' Season Record [ 0-0-1 ]

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

It's even'd out. I got 2 positions I needed help in, and he did too. and I gave him a 2nd rounder.

But ur also getting 3 young players one of which is a 94 and hes getting a bunch of low 80 guys half of whom are old but if he still agrees ill approve it

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

I'm giving him a Better QB that he wanted, and a better WR no matter what.

I need some secondary, and want to build around my defense.

_________________
Miami Dolphins' Season Record [ 0-0-1 ]

lebronzoom · Admin Posts: 261 Join date: 2007-09-04

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

Phins get :

Byron Leftwich [82]
Reggie Nelson [82]
Marcus Stroud [94]
Ernest Wilford [77]
Dennis Northcutt [74]

Jags get :

Trent Green [85]
Renaldo Hill [80]
Keith Traylor [84]
Marty Booker [82]
Kelly Campbell [66]
MIA's 2nd Round Pick

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

I'm giving him a Better QB that he wanted, and a better WR no matter what.

I need some secondary, and want to build around my defense.

one team needs a DT and MLB (lets call them team A)
another team needs a QB and WR (lets call them team B)

team A gets an 85 DT and an 85 MLB, theyre improving at two positions
team B gets a 90 QB and a 90 WR, theyre improving at two positions

thats obviously not fair and its basically the same reason here

the 2nd round pick isnt very good, maybe worth a player 80 ovr, lets go out on a limb and cancel him with leftwich
Stroud is worth Green, Hill, Booker and Traylor alone

Nelson Wilford and Northcut for a 66 player?

no, this definately needs to be reworked

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

Great explaining lebron, this definetly needs to be reworked

poeticpyro

Yeah, Dolphins need to give more IMO as well.

It needs to be re-worked..

_________________

Oakland Raider

2007 Season

0 - 0

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

I need to improve a little bit on offense, and same with defense with my secondary....

He needs to improve in QB, and wants another WR...

I gave him Green, 85 old but still great average QB. He's giving a injury pronish QB in Byron.

Booker is an 82 Rated WR....OLD BUT STILL GOOD HANDS. He's giving me Wilford, and Northcutt because of the even out so I gave him another WR, It didn't matter to him if he got it, or not.

Stroud is an amazing DT I needed in my DLine, and LB Core...I gave an average good DT in Traylor...OLD too.

I was willing to give him a 3rd, and 2nd rounders but he only wanted a 2nd.

Nelson was a young player I wanted to get my hands bc of my secondary. I gave him a great player in Hill....

Phins Needs - Defense, Secondary

Jags Needs - WR Replacement for their maybe retiring after a season 27 year old WR, and an average QB....85, or ^ atleast.

.....Phins got more defense with Stroud, and Nelson, less offense with Wilford, and Northcutt

Jags got more offense with Green, and Booker, and extra added Campbell, less defense with Hill, and Traylor, and maybe a Future replacement on DT with 2nd Round Pick or another position that they need.

....I don't know how you guys judge a player by the attributes...Look at Jake Delhomme, Last year he was a 90+ QB, and now his a 85 WTF?! is up with that, and Now Panthers could go on switching the starting QB Jake for the young David Carr......same thing on defense for other teams. This is fair, is some way possible.

_________________
Miami Dolphins' Season Record [ 0-0-1 ]

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

Dude its a horrible trade... get over it and rework it

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

Wow! Are you 2 faced?!, You just told me a few mins ago that you said if the other guy agreed on this, You will approve it....

_________________
Miami Dolphins' Season Record [ 0-0-1 ]

lebronzoom · Admin Posts: 261 Join date: 2007-09-04

3o5TiLLIDiE wrote:

I need to improve a little bit on offense, and same with defense with my secondary....

He needs to improve in QB, and wants another WR...

I gave him Green, 85 old but still great average QB. He's giving a injury pronish QB in Byron.

Booker is an 82 Rated WR....OLD BUT STILL GOOD HANDS. He's giving me Wilford, and Northcutt because of the even out so I gave him another WR, It didn't matter to him if he got it, or not.

Stroud is an amazing DT I needed in my DLine, and LB Core...I gave an average good DT in Traylor...OLD too.

I was willing to give him a 3rd, and 2nd rounders but he only wanted a 2nd.

Nelson was a young player I wanted to get my hands bc of my secondary. I gave him a great player in Hill....

Phins Needs - Defense, Secondary

Jags Needs - WR Replacement for their maybe retiring after a season 27 year old WR, and an average QB....85, or ^ atleast.

.....Phins got more defense with Stroud, and Nelson, less offense with Wilford, and Northcutt

Jags got more offense with Green, and Booker, and extra added Campbell, less defense with Hill, and Traylor, and maybe a Future replacement on DT with 2nd Round Pick or another position that they need.

....I don't know how you guys judge a player by the attributes...Look at Jake Delhomme, Last year he was a 90+ QB, and now his a 85 WTF?! is up with that, and Now Panthers could go on switching the starting QB Jake for the young David Carr......same thing on defense for other teams. This is fair, is some way possible.

yea but the thing is this is a madden league, not real life. And like I said before, just because both teams are improving at a couple of positions, doesnt mean its a fair trade, that certainly is taken into consideration, but dude you gotta add like an 85 into this one for it to be approvable.

Bookers not going to be getting any better in madden
Byron will be getting better, hes only 27 years old and has insane throwing power
Stroud is one of the best DTs in the game, still has room to improve seeing as he's under 30
Traylor, old and wont be getting any better
2nd rounder isnt very good
Green is a brutal QB and is very old, might play for ONE season (this is a multi-year league).
Griffins a great rookie that has potential shooting out his ass

no, this trades unfair dude, just go and tweek it a bit
an 85 (around 27-29 years old) player or a 1st rounder would do it but right now this trades off.

3o5TiLLIDiE · Posts: 91 Join date: 2007-09-10 Age: 18 Location: Miami, FL

What if I add in a 4th round pick, or a 3rd?

_________________
Miami Dolphins' Season Record [ 0-0-1 ]