Panthers & Broncos Trade(Approved)

Zsirvone28 · Subject: Panthers & Broncos Trade(Approved) Thu Sep 13, 2007 5:05 pm

Panthers get:
Daniel Graham 88
Brandon Marshall 80
Rod Smith 83
2008 4th round R pick

Broncos get:
David Carr 82
Jordan Gross 90
Eric Coleman 82

_________________
2007 Denver Broncos 0-0

SoxNats07 · Posts: 157 Join date: 2007-09-04 Age: 16

Zsirvone28 wrote:

Panthers get:
Daniel Graham 88
Brandon Marshall 80
Rod Smith 83
2008 4th round R pick

Broncos get:
David Carr 82
Jordan Gross 90
Eric Coleman 82

kinda iffy on this one...

graham=gross
marshall+4th=coleman
the difference between a young QB and a very old WR with 1 pt rating dif isnt good enough IMO

ill hear some other opinions tho

nieemo · Posts: 113 Join date: 2007-09-04

i agree

_________________

thanks zoooooooooooooom

Dman · Posts: 112 Join date: 2007-09-06

I agree with sox

nieemo · Posts: 113 Join date: 2007-09-04

wat if he changed a 4th to a 3rd

_________________

thanks zoooooooooooooom

Zsirvone28 · Subject: Re: Panthers & Broncos Trade(Approved) Thu Sep 13, 2007 5:35 pm

It's not all about points though... It's about how these players effect their new teams. I get a starting RT, and backup QB and S. He gets a starting TE, a pick, and two solid slot WRs... If you think about it, if he moves Minter to FS... then he actually upgrades his secondary when he trades Coleman. So I mean, grade it as you want... I think it's pretty dam fair.

_________________
2007 Denver Broncos 0-0

Zsirvone28 · Subject: Re: Panthers & Broncos Trade(Approved) Thu Sep 13, 2007 6:31 pm

Can we get some votes on this?..

_________________
2007 Denver Broncos 0-0

nieemo · Posts: 113 Join date: 2007-09-04

yea i think this is fair and i need this trade to happen cause i already picked a replacemnt for gross in the FA draft

_________________

thanks zoooooooooooooom

PatsTown · Admin Posts: 400 Join date: 2007-08-13

I think this trade is fair, I agree with what sox said but I would put Graham>Gross. But thats just my opinion.

_________________

Zoom did it.

silvablitz · Posts: 19 Join date: 2007-09-04

i can say yes here

nieemo · Posts: 113 Join date: 2007-09-04

is this approved

_________________

thanks zoooooooooooooom

PatsTown · Admin Posts: 400 Join date: 2007-08-13

PROCESSING TIME 7:50 EST

_________________

Zoom did it.

Brianeal23 · Posts: 65 Join date: 2007-09-07

This seems relatively fair... if I would change anything I would say the pick being given should be higher because a TE at 88 ovr is still not all that valuable. But other than that good trade.