Panthers - Skins trade(Denied)

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

titans0021 wrote:

Wow you guys are getting really picky.

Muhammed is ancient and is only an 86 who will either retire at the end of the season or go down to like an 82.
Marshall is a young, decent WR who can get better but he is only 80 overall.

90+ OT's are tough to get in Madden and its not as though Jansen is really old.

This trade is almost right down the middle and to decline it is kind of sad.

No their not... almost every team has a 90 plus OT and 5-6 teams have 2

titans0021 · Posts: 77 Join date: 2007-09-04

Their are 19 90+ OT in Madden and 18 90+ WRs, just thought I'd point that out

poeticpyro · Subject: Re: Panthers - Skins trade(Denied) Sat Sep 15, 2007 11:08 pm

thats why I said 89+, cause I know there aren't that many 90+ WRs.

a WR can be amazingly good at the 85+ mark, while you look at G/T/C at 85-86 and they blow.

Anyways, at the 89+ mark it looks like this:

89+ WR = 24

89+ C = 10
89+ G = 19
89+ T = 23

_________________

Oakland Raider

2007 Season

0 - 0

titans0021 · Posts: 77 Join date: 2007-09-04

I know pyro, thats why i'm saying this should be approved.

It's a 90 OT for a very very old 86 WR and an 80 young WR,

SimsZilla · Posts: 118 Join date: 2007-09-08

well this sucks.

mksadng · Admin Posts: 156 Join date: 2007-09-04

poeticpyro wrote:

thats why I said 89+, cause I know there aren't that many 90+ WRs.

a WR can be amazingly good at the 85+ mark, while you look at G/T/C at 85-86 and they blow.

Anyways, at the 89+ mark it looks like this:

89+ WR = 24

89+ C = 10
89+ G = 19
89+ T = 23

no they cant, not in simulation. look at soxnats league and look at the top 10 receivers, what do they all have in common? they're all 90+. WRs are valued much higher then offensive lineman thats just the way it is and i know for a fact he could get a 90 OT and an 85 OG for those two receivers.

poeticpyro · Subject: Re: Panthers - Skins trade(Denied) Sun Sep 16, 2007 1:12 pm

thats crazy.

If you show me ANY NFL team that would give up a 90 OT and an 85 OG for a decent receiver and I'll show you the Detroit Lions and their losing record.

Look in next years draft and tell me how many pretty damn good WRs come out and how many OL period come out that are considered to be good, let alone decent.

OL is MUCH more valuable in football. You can have great WR talent on your team (Arizona/Detroit/Houston) and have no line and look at the results..